The Mystery of disappearing Pudding Pops!
August 19, 2006 – 1:15 pmLadies and gentleman I have for you a newly found treat.
Behold the Pudding Pop Recipe.
No I have no clue if they really taste the same. But I am trying it this weekend and I will report back.
I can’t seem to find any history of what happened to the real pudding pops either. Scarry? Maybe. I just know I am not the only one that misses them. They brought back the name but not the "real" thing yet.
Any who!
Recipe for Pudding Pops
2 cups cold milk
1 package (4-serving size) Jell-O Instant Pudding and Pie Mix
6 (5-oz) paper cups
6 popsicle sticks
Beat pudding mix and milk together, at least two minutes. Spoon into cups. Insert popsicle stick in center of each cup. Freeze 5 hours (or overnight). To remove pop from cup, place bottom of cup in warm water for 15 seconds. Press firmly on bottom of cup and push pop out. Don’t pull on the popsicle stick.
TheScrapbookingCricut.com
10 Responses to “The Mystery of disappearing Pudding Pops!”
Yeah, what did happen to pudding pops? I loved those, I would have killed for those when I was preggo. Thanks for the recipe, I’m totally going to the store in the morning!
By Nikkie on Aug 19, 2006
isn’t that just the standard recipe off the box + sticks and freezing? I may have to try it. I loved pudding pops, too- especially the layer of ice that formed on the sides. Creamies are similar, but not as lovely as I remember pudding pops to be.
By Valarie on Aug 19, 2006
I love this. So excited! I can’t believe I wasn’t the only one to think of pudding pops from your last post. YOu have to let me know how they are. What I really want to know about is whether or not they have the thin layer of ice on the outside of them. To me, it was fascinating.
By Beth on Aug 20, 2006
Yum! But in my next life if I am lactose intolerant again? I’m asking for a refund.
By bon on Aug 20, 2006
I actually CALLED Jello in college to find out what happened to them… they said there wasn’t enough interest so they pulled them off the market. Are you Kidding?!? They’re fabulous… and such a part of my childhood. Maybe if we all call them (in mass) they’ll bring the real ones back?
By GranolaGirl on Aug 20, 2006
Wow. My comment started a movement. Whoda thought? I will try the pudding pop recipe but I know it can’t possibly be the same as when Bill Cosby used to peddle them.
Chocolate and vanilla swirl. MMMMMM.
By karen on Aug 22, 2006
Oh that I could find instant pudding here. They sound like something I could eat!
By Gabriela on Aug 22, 2006
Ahhhh…nostalgia! My grandma would make them for us when we were little. Tupperware used to sell molds that were in the same shape as the “real” pudding pops. I bet you could find some on e-bay.
By Stephanie on Aug 22, 2006
You can buy push-up molds at Williams Sonoma, too.
By karen on Aug 22, 2006
i totally dig pudding pops- i rememebr eating a giant box of them with my friend friend and his sister so he could use the sticks to make a diorama of a baseball field- his mom freaked!
and 9lb 9oz babes rock- i mean at least at that size you can’t forget you’re gave birth ;>
By smartmama on Aug 23, 2006